Photosynthetic
dinoflagellates are important primary producers in marine ecosystems; however certain
species can cause harmful agal blooms (HAB’s). These
species are usually found in warmer and nutrient rich waters. Since these HAB
events are increasing in frequency, and can be a risk to human health, the
search for some way to control or reduce blooms has started. It has been proposed, by
Taylor in 1968, that the use of specific dinoflagellate parasites (eg Syndiniales
Amoebophrya) could be used as a
biological control. However at the time his ideas were dismissed due to a lack
of evidence. The aim of this study was to examine how the abundance and diversity
of dinoflagellate parasites influenced their host populations in natural environments.
A
marine coastal estuary (the Penzé River,
northern Brittany, France) was sampled for 3 consecutive years (2004 to 2006)
in the months May to June. During those months, every year, the dominant
dinoflagellate was observed to change weekly. These are the species: Heterocapsa rotundata, Scrippsiella
trochoidea, Alexandrim minutum and H.
triquetra. There was infection by
Syndiniales in all of the observed dinoflagellates, even when the population
was small. The frequency of the parasitized dinoflagellates reached 46% with a
mean value of 21% during the summer which corresponded to the previous
literature.
The
specificity of the four mane parasitic clades was detected by using FISH,
which, every year, identified four main clades of Syndiniales. Clade 1 is associated
with the decline of H. rotundata, clades 2, 3, and 14 appeared in late June. Each clade was associated the same single
dinoflagellate species every year : clades 1, 2, and 14 infected the
dinoflagellates H. rotundata, S. trochoidea, and H. triquetra, respectively. None
of the major clades seemed to be specific to the toxic dinoflagellate A.
minutum.
The
parasites, in the case of A. minutum, spreads by deforming and expanding the
dinoflagellate cells, until the host cell bursts the cell wall and elongates
into a swimming structure (the vermiform stage). Each vermiform structure breaks
into up to 400 dinospores within a few hours; each of which is able to
re-infect host cells. This enables the parasite to counter the
rapid the growth rate of the host. These dinospores are only detectable within
10 days of their release. The dinoflagellate population decreased in
correlation with the free-living form of the parasite. However the growth of
the other species of dinoflagellate species did not decline despite the large
amount of dinospores produced which suggests that the parasites are species
specific. There were examples of when parasites attacked non-optimum host cells
however no mature trophonts were found.
To
explore the evolutionary history and the genetic microdiversity the authors
employed Tajima’s test. Clades 1 and 3 had significantly negative results
suggesting the recent evolution or rapid evolution divergence from strong
selection pressure. Clades 2 and 14 were shown to be ancient, evolutionary
wise. Clade 3 weren’t detected targeting any cells.
A. minutum blooms in the Penzé estuary were first
recorded in 1994. They re-occurred over the next 9 years until the parasites
started to regulate the population. They are still present in the ecosystem
however the blooms of A. minutum no
longer occur. Although this wasn’t an anthropogenic introduction of the
parasites, it could be an example of how parasitic control of HAB’s could be
used to decrease the number or the extent of marine agal blooms.
Chambouvet, Aurelie, et al. "Control of toxic marine dinoflagellate blooms by serial parasitic killers." Science 322.5905 (2008): 1254-1257.
http://www.sciencemag.org/content/322/5905/1254.short
Hi Sam, an interesting article and a nice overlap between modules; marine microbes and speciation & diversity. This paper, to me, is a great testament for letting nature to deal with itself. I wonder what the impacts would have been if proposal by Taylor went ahead? Due to the survey being on a marine coastal estuary, where there any mention of over-enriching (a big component of agal blooms)? Instead of tackling the HABs head on, perhaps a better approach would have been to look into the impacts of anthropogenic sources of phosphorus and nitrogen, i.e.; runoff and erosion from fertilised agricultural areas, deforestation, and sewage effluent to name a few.
ReplyDeleteHi Dean,
ReplyDeleteThey did mention a couple of times that the frequency and volume of the blooms increase due to nutrient run-off, however they didn't focus on the issue. I personally believe that attacking the problem at the source is a much more effective and long-term solution than just dealing with the symptoms. However finding a balance between agricultural/industrial needs and the environment's capacity for nutrient enrichment will be a difficult and long process, especially with growing populations. Untill a solution is found this sort of study, in the short-term, could be usefull.
Hi Sam,
ReplyDeleteInteresting post - it links quite well to my latest one (have a read)! Is the idea behind this study to actually infect the HAB manually? If so it would be interesting if the authors thought about the consequences to the ecosystem this may have.