Vibriosis
is a serious condition that affects many species in the marine environment, it
is though that susceptibility in marine species changes depending on the life
stage of the organism. Crustaceans have seen to be susceptible to many
vibrio-induced infections and are prone to attack from a wide range of species
including V. alginolyticus, V. fluvialis, V. harveyi and V. vulnificus.
However, our knowledge of the importance of vibrios in Crustacea is limited to few
studies only using a small number of species, including shrimp and the blue
crab. This study looks at the importance of vibrios in infection of juvenile
stages of the edible crab, Cancer pagurus.
It has been previously suggested that the juvenile life stage is a ‘bottleneck’
for survival to adulthood, meaning the importance of susceptibility to
virbriosis is highest at this point, allowing for optimal infection and
bacterial septicaemia to persist.
Juvenile C. pagarus were collected from Mumbles Head
and Gower Penisula, Swansea, UK. Their haemolymph was extracted and aseptically
plated onto saline tryptone soya agar (TSA) and thiosulfate citrate bile salts
sucrose agar (TCBS). Colonies were left to form at 25ᵒC for 2-5 days and a
baseline of 2000 colony forming units (CFU) mL-1 was used as an
indication of the extent of bacterial septicaemia, below this level it was
assumed to be low severity infection.
After
incubation, the morphological characteristics of the bacteria were recorded,
this showed the bacterial colonies from the haemolymph to be highly variable. 33%
of the samples had vibrio-like bacteria culturable on TSA, however only 1% were
of high severity (>2000 CFU mL-1). This bacterial susceptibility was shown
to have no influence by carapace damage or limb loss which contrasts to previous
studies considering the blue crab, which was shown to be more prone to
bacterial infection if damaged or missing limbs. The extent of low level
infection was shown to be influenced by the stage of moult, post-moult crabs
with softer, more vulnerable cuticles were shown to have significantly higher
levels of bacterial haemolymph infection. Infection was also shown to be of
higher persistence in the summer to autumn months when sea surface temperatures
were highest. This has been shown to be typical of Virbio species as it has
been shown that higher water temperatures often favour their replication.
Gill
damage was measured using histological studies, it showed correlation between
cases of high level of haemolymph infection, this is suggested to be either the
route of entry of the infecting bacteria or a resulting defect of septicaemia.
Previous studies have shown nodule formation in Carcinus maenus to be a defence mechanism for dealing with bacterial septicaemia.
This study
also looked at the effect of the dinoflagellate, Hematodinium, on bacterial infection. The presence of Hematodinium in the crabs hepatopancreas
correlated with reduced bacterial infection, it is therefore thought that a competitive
interaction exists between this dinoflagellate and bacterial infection as a
possible result of phagocytic action.
Molecular
analysis of 16s rRNA was used to identify the infecting agents colonies with
the most potential for vibrio species from 3 separate samples. The colonies
were amplified with PCR, sequenced by MWG eurofins operon and searched using
BLAST and the Ribosomal Database project II using an identity threshold of 99%.
All three of the tested colonies showed highest similarity to Virbio spp, with two out of the three
being most similar to Vibrio pectenicida.
These V.pectenicida colonies were only
cultureable on the TSA agar, suggesting that this study may have had
limitations by using TCBS agar which may have led to an underestimation of vibrio
species in the samples.
This study
showed Vibrio species to be present in juvenile C. pagarus, however there was little identification of the species
contributing to infection in the blood. To further analyse the crab septicaemia,
identification of the more prevalent colonies and correlation between the
damage to the crabs and the bacteria present would be needed. However, they did
show that bacterial infection is significantly reduced with the presence of the
dinoflagellate Hematodinium spp.,
showing there is a potential of competitive and perhaps phagocytic activity
between these two communities, further study into the relationship between them
would be recommended.
Smith, A.,
Whitten, M., Hirschle, L., Pope, E., Wootton, E., Vogan, C. and Rowley, A.
(2013). Bacterial septicaemia in prerecruit edible crabs, Cancer pagurus L. Journal of Fish Disease, 37, 8, 729-737.
Hey Freya, nice post really fits in well to what we are currently studying in lectures and it's incredible vibrios can infect from mammals to fish to crustaceans! how many edible crabs did they sample please? did they say how many of the crabs had the vibrio bacteria in their haemolymph- this could give an idea of ratios in populations on infected: non- infected.When they say they had softer cuticles, how did they know this wasn't a symptom of the bacterial infection- not a cause? I definitely think the Hematodinium and vibrio relationship needs to be investigated further!!!
ReplyDeleteHi Elyssa, they surveyed 463 crabs in total which was a pretty big sample size, but they did only do molecular analysis on 3 of these samples as these 3 were the only ones to show any potential to be vibrio species. This shows the proportion of vibrios in the population is relatively low but there could be potential in the other samples, more molecular analysis would be needed to determine that! Its good point that the virus could have an effect on the softness of the crab shell, I've read that vibrio species have been isolated from tiger prawns with soft shell disease so maybe there is a correlation there it would be interesting to look in to!!
DeleteThats extremely low-maybe this dinoflaggelate relationship is only found in this species of crab (or others that don't have vibrio) which prevents them from infection! Thanks :)
DeleteHi Freya,
ReplyDeleteI was just wondering if the paper provided any rationale behind the use of >2000 CFU as an indicator of the extent of bacterial infection?
Also, this study examined the microbes they could culture,do you think that other, non-culturable microbes could be playing some role in infection?
Thanks
Jack
Hi Jack, they used the >2000 CFU mL-1 baseline figure to account for any contamination in the samples that could have happened whilst bleeding the crabs. They gave no exact rationale but I am assuming that 2000 CFU mL-1 is a maximum level of contamination likely to be in the samples. As for the role of VBNC organisms, I think this is an area that definitely needs looking into as these sorts of organisms are often a hidden cause of disease, it could be worth using an insitu detection method to gain an idea of the extent VBNC organisms are present. The study also used TCBS agar which has previously been shown to underestimated bacteria numbers, so perhaps a less selective medium would have accounted for more of the non-cultured organisms!
Delete