Harmful algal blooms (HABs) can cause mass mortality of fish
and other aquatic organisms through the depletion of oxygen from the water, the
contamination of the surrounding air, blockage of gills and production of
toxins and reactive oxygen species. HABs are becoming a global issue with
recurrent cases along many coastal areas. Many of the commonly used techniques
to control HABs (e.g. ozonation, chlorination, ultrasonic treatment, etc.) have
limited success and also have the capacity to disrupt marine ecosystems. Safer
biological strategies for mitigating HABs have been proposed that utilise
marine bacteria, algal viruses, protozoa and macrophytes. Kang et al., (2015) set
out to investigate the potential use of virus-like particles (VLPs) to deliver
algicidal compounds directly to harmful algae.
The toxic dinoflagellate Heterocapsa
circularisquama is widely spread along the Chinese coast from Japan to Hong
Kong and causes severe die-off of cultured clams, mussels, razor shells and
oysters. The capsid protein of HcRNAV34, a single stranded RNA virus that
infects and lyses H. circularisquama,
produced from Escherichia coli was self-assembled into VLPs in
vitro and employed as a carrier for the potent algicidal compound
thiazolidinedione 49 (TD49). The self-assembled VLPs were significantly smaller
than the authentic HcRNAV34 capsid reflecting the various morphological forms a
virion may adopt during maturation. However, despite this difference in size,
the TD49-HcRNAV34 VLP showed the same host specificity as the native particles.
The TD49-encapsidated VLPs showed a more potent target-specific algicidal
effect than TD49 alone by increasing TD49 local concentrations near the target
cells. In contrast, encapsulated TD49 protected non-host cells at low
concentrations (0.5μM) even after 72h. Interestingly, at 5.0μM the VLP lost
their protective effect for non-host cells by 72h and resulted in higher growth
inhibition rates that free TD49. One of the possible explanations for this is
the protection of TD49 by VLP from degradation, hence prolonging its otherwise
short half-life.
VLPs have some major advantages for the delivery of
algicidal compounds to harmful algae such as high target specificity and thus
protection of non-target species, the use of a naturally occurring biodegradable
protein and stabilisation of the algicidal compound from degradation in sea
water. However, the stabilisation of the algicidal compounds could also be considered
a disadvantage as it can increase the effect on non-target species once the
VLPs have degraded as it makes the algicidal compounds linger around for longer.
More work needs to be done on the production and stability of VLPs as HABs can
be comprised of more than one strain and different types of VLPs would need to
be deployed. It would also be interesting to test the efficiency of other algicidal
compounds while encapsulated in VLPs and see whether the findings of this paper
apply to other compounds as well.
Kang,
B. S., Eom, C. Y., Kim, W., Ju, S. Y., Ryu, J., Han, G. H., ... & Kim, S.
W. (2015). Construction of target‐specific virus‐like particles for the delivery of algicidal compounds to harmful algae. Environmental
microbiology, 17(4), 1463-1474
Hi Maria,
ReplyDeleteI have actually reviewed that study in March - but its good to read about it again! I think its a really interesting approach to deal with HABs. Tom made a good point that it might be quite an expensive method. What do you think?
I think you make a really good point there that the algicidal compounds linger around for longer might be a dissatvantage. In what form do you think could it affect non-target species?
Did you find out about any alternative algacidal compounds that would work?
Thanks :)
Hi Tabea,
ReplyDeleteI didn’t realise you had reviewed it as well. I should have check more carefully. Producing the VLPs can be very costly but there are different methods that can be employed such as fermentation (commonly used in vaccine production) so it would be interesting to see which would be most cost-effective. In regards to the next question, the target organisms would be initially killed but once the VLPs degrade the reminder of the algicidal compounds would be free to kill non-target species and as pointed out by this study at higher concentration there was higher growth inhibition of non-target species after 72h of incubation with encapsulated TD49 when compared to free TD49. There are many algicidal compounds on the market such as copper sulphate, aponin and other surfactants and it would be interesting to test their efficiency while encapsulated in VLPs.